Home Planning & Renovations

Pros and Cons of Hiring a General Contractor

By Mia Cetkovic


Embarking on a home renovation or construction project in New York City presents a unique set of challenges and decisions. Interestingly, one of the most significant is hiring a general contractor.

General contractors play a pivotal role in the success of construction projects, overseeing every aspect from initial planning to the final touches. The advantages of hiring a general contractor in NY include comprehensive project management and access to skilled subcontractors.

However, while their expertise can be invaluable, weighing the pros and cons is essential to make an informed decision that best suits your project’s needs. Thankfully, this article discusses the pros and cons of hiring a general contractor.

Why Choose a General Contractor?

general contractor is essential for the success of a major home remodeling project. While hiring one can be expensive, their pros outweigh their cons in the long run. Here are the pros of hiring a general contractor in New York.

Expertise and Experience

General contractors bring a wealth of knowledge and experience to your project. They deeply understand NYC construction processes, building codes, and regulations. This expertise ensures that your project meets all legal requirements, avoiding costly fines and delays.

Time and Stress Savings

Managing a construction project can be time-consuming and stressful. Hiring a general contractor relieves you of the day-to-day management, allowing you to focus on your priorities. They coordinate with subcontractors, obtain necessary permits, and ensure the project stays on schedule.

Access to a Network of Skilled Subcontractors

General contractors have established relationships with various skilled subcontractors. They know whom to call for each aspect of the project, from plumbing and electrical work to carpentry and painting. This access can lead to higher quality workmanship and potentially lower costs due to their existing relationships.

Comprehensive Project Management

General contractors oversee all project phases, from planning and design to construction and cleanup. They handle unexpected issues, making decisions in your best interest while keeping you informed. This comprehensive management approach can ensure a smoother process and a more cohesive final product.

Financial Oversight and Budget Management

With experience in budgeting for construction projects, general contractors can provide accurate estimates and keep expenses within the agreed budget. They also handle payments to subcontractors and suppliers, ensuring your project finances are well managed.

Related Article: What is the Best Way to Find a Great General Contractor?

general contractors oversee project phases

Cons of Hiring a General Contractor

Hiring a general contractor may help you save time and stress, but it often comes at a high cost and requires less project control. Here are the downsides of hiring a general contractor.


Hiring a general contractor adds expense to your project. They charge for their services, which can be a percentage of the total project cost or a fixed fee. While their expertise provides value, it’s essential to consider whether your budget can accommodate this cost.

Less Direct Control

While a general contractor efficiently manages the project, you may feel less control over the day-to-day decisions. Some homeowners prefer to be more hands-on with their projects, and working through a contractor might feel limiting.

Potential for Miscommunication

Communicating your vision and expectations through a general contractor to subcontractors can sometimes lead to misinterpretation. It’s crucial to maintain open lines of communication and ensure that your contractor fully understands your goals for the project.

Dependence on the Contractor’s Schedule

Your project timeline may be dependent on the contractor’s availability and schedule. General contractors manage multiple projects simultaneously, which could impact your project’s start date or progression.

How to Choose a General Contractor

Before starting a home renovation project, it is wise to consider the pros and cons of hiring a general contractor. After hiring a general contractor, the next step is choosing a suitable one for your project.

Here are some steps to help you choose a reliable and competent general contractor for a home remodel:

  • Define Your Project Scope: Before searching for a contractor, clearly define your project’s scope, including budget, timeline, and specific requirements. Understanding your needs will help you communicate effectively with potential contractors.
  • Research and Gather Recommendations: Ask friends, family, and colleagues for recommendations. Additionally, check online review platforms, contractor directories, and industry associations for reputable contractors in your area. Look for contractors with positive reviews, relevant experience, and a good reputation.
  • Check Licenses and Credentials: Among the things to look for in a general contractor is their licensing and credentials. Ensure the general contractor holds all licenses and certifications required by your state or local jurisdiction. Check if they are bonded and insured, which protects you in case of accidents, property damage, or incomplete work.
  • Verify Experience and Expertise: Look for a contractor with experience in projects similar to yours. Ask for examples of past projects, client references, and portfolios to assess the quality of their workmanship. A contractor with relevant experience is more likely to understand the intricacies of your project and deliver satisfactory results.
  • Request Detailed Bids: Obtain written bids from multiple contractors outlining the scope of work, materials, labour costs, project timeline, payment schedule, and additional fees or expenses. Compare bids carefully to ensure they cover all aspects of your project and are transparent about costs.
  • Check References and Reviews: Contact references provided by the contractor and ask about their experience working with them. Additionally, research online reviews and testimonials to gauge client satisfaction and identify any red flags or recurring issues.

Related Article: An Upper West Side NYC Apartment Gets A Bright and Colorful Remodel

checking contractor reviews and projects

Hire Expert General Contractor in New York

Whether to hire a general contractor for your NYC home renovation or construction project depends on several factors, including your budget and project complexity. The benefits of hiring a general contractor—expertise, stress reduction, and comprehensive project management—can significantly outweigh the cons for many homeowners.

However, conducting thorough research and choosing a contractor with a solid reputation, like MyHome US, is crucial to ensure a successful collaboration.

Let MyHome US help you achieve your vision with less stress, ensuring a renovation or construction project that meets or exceeds your expectations.

Call us today at 212.666.2888.